Cooling Towers And Rooftop Decks

By David P. Callan, PE, CEM, LEED AP, HBDP, Julia and qcxp Ingersoll, PE
From the June 2021 Concern

T he prevalence of rooftop seating areas for the pleasure of creating occupants has extended across industry sectors. A large number of buildings, from workplaces to hospitals, universities, and residential complexes, are actually all looking to provide these elevated locations to patrons and workers for entertainment and every day escape. The onset and continued impact of the COVID-19 pandemic spurred the expansion or creation of the outdoor spaces.

But several building owners and service managers may not recognize that alongside the seating and greenery in these areas exists a possible threat to occupant health-rooftop cooling towers. Legionella bacterias isn’t uncommon to rooftop cooling towers. Whenever your roof deck close by is, the opportunity for Legionnaires’ Illness to distribute rises-and this consideration is becoming more frequent as these spaces are more popular.

Together with the seating and landscaping on rooftop decks appears a potential risk to occupant health-rooftop cooling towers-which may raise the distribute of Legionnaires’ Disease.(Photograph: Adobe Share/ Leslie C. Saber)

Legionnaires’ Condition And Avoiding Its Distribute

Legionella germs can grow in a building’s condenser water program with open-cellular cooling towers as the required heat range of condenser drinking water (85°F to 100°F) may be the same temperature where Legionella bacteria flourishes. After that, the bacterias are spread through the inhalation of mist or fog easily. Much like COVID‐19, but with an increased fatality rate of 5‐10%¹, Legionnaires’ condition spreads through drinking water droplets small sufficient for people to breathe.

Whenever a building’s cooling tower gets rid of and exchanges warmth from the within of a building, a few of the drinking water evaporates, and some drinking water will be entrained in the atmosphere and launched from the very best of the tower in a cloud-like mist. If the coolant system is not home maintained and constructed, this mist could infect nearby gatherers benefiting from a patio rooftop space easily.

To help keep patrons safe, constructing owners and facility supervisors should:

1. Disinfect properly. Because it’s possible for legionella bacteria to cultivate in cooling tower drinking water, it’s vital to employ chemically-treated drinking water in the cooling tower loop frequently to get rid of any trace of the germs. Building proprietors can mitigate this danger by investing in far better and efficient cleaning devices and applying a tiered servicing intend to keep some degree of operations while upkeep occurs. The Occupational Protection and Health Management (OSHA) recommends washing cooling towers at the very least twice per year.

2. Decrease the drift. The mist or fog launched from the cooling towers is called drift. Drift eliminators may be used to reduce the quantity of water, and for that reason harmful bacteria departing the cooling tower by capturing the droplets and returning them back to the tower. A competent drift eliminator will keep drift losses to significantly less than 0.01%² of the recirculating water flow rate.

Drift eliminators can play an integral role in performance and water financial savings for the facility. And there are a number of considerations when choosing them yet, including place in the tower, working heat, water loading, and surroundings velocity. The addition of drift eliminators on existing equipment should be analyzed to make sure equipment capacities are managed carefully.

In the same way proper cleaning is necessary for the cooling tower, twice each year drift eliminators ought to be washed and flushed at the least.

3. Move aside. Maintain occupants as a long way away from rooftop cooling towers as you possibly can, if they’re downwind especially. Consider the prevailing winds because a drift could be carried by these circumstances for long distances. The aside occupants are farther, the more period the surroundings has to focus on the drift and suspended drinking water to permit water to evaporate. Furthermore consider any kind of physical separations it is possible to put in between your cooling tower and the social people.

Though range reduces the prospect of contact with the bacteria, it generally does not get rid of the risk. In particular weather conditions, cooling tower drift from industrial cooling towers might traveling 100 feet or even more before water evaporates. Large-scale commercial cooling towers have also lengthier ranges of a mile or even more.

DO YOU WANT Cooling Towers?

In most of creating owners and facility supervisors, cooling towers are usually an important building component, for big facilities that support huge heat loads especially. Cooling towers certainly are a mainstay for hotels, industrial buildings, and university campuses. Hospitals and commercial plants, of their size regardless, are also applicants for cooling towers because they support a number of apparatus that generates extra temperature within the space, requiring the substantial assist associated with cooling towers thereby.

Atmosphere cooled systems can be a great option to the rooftop cooling tower for smaller sized facilities. Having an air-cooled program, there’s no basin of drinking water, reducing its capability to spread bacteria-infected drinking water through the air therefore. Instead, the machine functions by rejecting heat to the outside air flow by increasing the temp of the air, not really the moisture articles of the new air through evaporation.

A 3rd, far better system choice may be a fluid cooler, which uses a less of domestic water sprayed on coils, which reject heat to the atmosphere. These systems certainly are a great choice for medium-sized buildings since they utilize considerably less water than evaporative cooling towers. Similarly, an adiabatic fluid cooler is really a kind of fluid cooler that runs on the less of domestic water to precool the air that’s approved over coils. These systems are usually befitting buildings in drier environments and could function as right choice for the facility.

Consider Extra Care

As more organizations choose rooftop decks to create yard to employees and patrons, extra consideration should be used when constructing the proper cooling system for every building. Building owners and facility operators who manage rooftops with cooling towers must supply the design and layout of these rooftop amenities careful considered to ensure occupants stay safe.


¹ World Health Organization:

Callan, President and CEO of Callan Consulting Engineers , has been renovating existing buildings and designing new cost-effective, high-performing buildings for a lot more than 25 years around the world. Ingersoll will be associate principal and senior mechanical engineer with Callan Consulting Engineers. She’s over a decade of experience in the look and construction of healthcare and laboratory facilities along with commercial office buildings.

Are you experiencing a comment? Share your ideas in the Comments section below, or deliver an e-mail to the Editor at [email safeguarded] .

Have a look at all of the recent HVAC Factor columns  from  Facility Executive  magazine.

Suggested Links: